City Development

Each day I post a new MCAT CARS Passage. This is for anyone who wants to practice for the CARS Section.

Every article is selected to meet the AAMC MCAT criteria for CARS.

Subscribe by email to receive a new practice passage each morning.

April 25, 2017 – MCAT CARS Passage

Question: What is your summary of the author’s main ideas. Post your own answer in the comments before reading those made by others.

Tacloban in the Philippines has now joined the growing list of cities – including New Orleans, Bangkok, Moscow, New York, Beijing, Rio de Janeiro, and Port-au-Prince, to name just a few – pummeled in recent years by climate catastrophes. Many of the world’s largest cities, built on seacoasts and rivers, face the threat of rising sea levels and intensifying storms. So the new global development agenda now taking shape should empower cities to help lead the way to sustainable development in the twenty-first century.

The importance of cities in today’s world economy is unprecedented. Until the Industrial Revolution, human history was overwhelmingly rural. Only around 10% of people lived in cities. Today, the share of urbanites is around 53% and is likely to rise to around 67% by 2050.

Because per capita incomes are higher in cities than in rural areas, the world’s cities today are estimated to account for more than 80% of global income, with the largest 600 accounting for around half. Most of the new jobs over the next few decades will be created in cities, offering livelihoods to hundreds of millions of young people and, as China and Brazil have demonstrated, helping to slash extreme poverty.

Cities are also the innovation hubs for public policy. Every day, mayors are called on to get the job done for residents. They are the ones responsible for providing safe water, garbage collection, safe housing, infrastructure, upgraded slums, protection from disasters, and emergency services when catastrophes hit. So it is not surprising that while national governments often are paralyzed by partisan politics, city governments foster action and innovation.

In the United States, for example, Martin O’Malley, Baltimore’s former mayor and now Maryland’s popular governor, pioneered the use of advanced information systems for urban management. New York City’s outgoing mayor, Michael Bloomberg, worked relentlessly to implement a new sustainability plan (called PlaNYC). And the city’s incoming mayor, Bill de Blasio, is championing a bold program of educational innovations to narrow the vast gaps in income, wealth, and opportunity that divide the city.

Sustainable development offers a new concept for the world economy in the twenty-first century. Rather than focusing solely on income, sustainable development encourages cities, countries, and the world to focus simultaneously on three goals: economic prosperity, social inclusion, and environmental sustainability.

Economic prosperity speaks for itself. Social inclusion means that all members of society – rich and poor, men and women, majority and minority groups – should have equal rights and equal opportunities to benefit from rising prosperity. And environmental sustainability means that we must reorient our economies and technologies to provide basic services like safe water and sanitation, combat human-induced climate change, and protect biodiversity. Achieving these three goals will require good governance, public finance, and effective institutions.

Cities will be in the front lines of the battle for sustainable development. Not only do they face direct threats; they also have the best opportunities to identify and deliver solutions. As high-density, high-productivity settlements, cities can provide greater access to services of all kinds – including energy, water, health, education, finance, media, transport, recycling, and research – than can most rural areas. The great challenge for cities is to provide this access inclusively and sustainably.

A significant part of the solution will come through advanced technologies, including information systems and materials science. The information and communications revolution has spawned the idea of the “smart city,” which places the relevant technologies at the heart of systems that collect and respond to information: smart power grids, smart transport networks (potentially including self-driving vehicles), and smart buildings and zoning.

The advances in materials science open the possibility of much more energy-efficient residences and commercial buildings. Cities also give rise to the opportunity to combine public utilities, as when urban power plants use the steam released in electricity generation to provide hot water and heating to residents.

Yet technology will be only part of the story. Cities need to upgrade their governance, to allow for a greater role for poorer and more marginalized communities, and to enable much more effective coordination across city lines when a metropolitan area is home to many individual cities. Metropolitan governance is therefore crucial, as smart cities require networks that operate at the metropolitan scale.
When the metropolitan scale is recognized, the importance of leading urban areas is even more remarkable. New York City has around 8.4 million people, but the NYC metropolitan area has roughly 25 million people, with an economy estimated at about $1.4 trillion per year. If this metropolitan area were a country, it would rank about 14th in the world in GDP terms.

A wise political doctrine known as subsidiarity holds that public-policy challenges should be assigned to the lowest level of government able to address them, thereby ensuring maximum democratic participation in problem solving and the greatest opportunity to tailor solutions to genuine local needs. While some issues – for example, a national highway or rail system – require national-level problem solving, many key challenges of sustainable development are best confronted at the urban level.

The world’s governments are now negotiating the Sustainable Development Goals, which will guide the world’s development agenda from 2015 to 2030. In an important meeting on September 25, the United Nations General Assembly agreed that the SDGs would be adopted at a global summit in September 2015, with the next two years used to select the priorities.

An urban SDG, promoting inclusive, productive, and resilient cities, would greatly empower tens of thousands of cities worldwide to take up the cause of sustainable development for their own citizens, their countries, and the world.

Adapted from Project Syndicate.

Review

Leave a comment below with what you understood to be the author’s main ideas. Ask about this daily passage in office hours/workshops for help.

Subscribe to my Daily CARS mailing list by entering your email.

The full list of daily articles is available here.

This was an article on Population Health.

Have a great day.
Jack Westin
MCAT CARS Instructor.
Contact Information

22 Comments


  1. Urban areas are most populated and hold lot of income. Need to increase sustainable development in these areas

    Reply

  2. CIty gov= innovations ex) Maryland
    Cities=SD + > rural ex) Smart City

    Reply

  3. cities important, sustainability important, public policy should be local

    Reply

  4. city development = important to world economy & hub for public policy = should be sustainable
    advanced tech & governance = crucial for sustainable development

    Reply

  5. sustainable development (cities) = city government

    Reply

  6. MIP: Cities important to economy/public policy (O’Malley, Bloomberg)
    MIP 2: Sustainable development – important for future

    Reply

  7. MIP: urban cities play an essential role in sustainable development; tone = neutral

    Reply

  8. With their rapidly growing number of residents and resources, urban cities play a critical role in directly impacting people’s lives and fostering sustainable future.

    Reply

  9. More sustainable development in cities: economic prosperity, social inclusion and environment sustainability. Tech and change in governance needed

    Reply

  10. Explaining how SDG will help the world and the role of urban cities in that process.

    Reply

  11. Climate change is a growing issue, and cities are important factors in combatting this problem to create a world that is inclusive and environmentally friendly

    Reply

  12. city living = increasing, sustainable development = new concept + 3 goals; author = neutral

    Reply

  13. MIPs: cities = important; do public policy –>action; sustainable development focus = econ ^, social inclusion, sustainability; technology –> solution; need inclusive governance + coordination

    Reply

  14. City=important in economy= making SDG. Tech is important for city development but not enough (CW).

    Reply

  15. cities = increasing + economy + policy hub
    SD= new concept + tech (cw) + good governance

    Reply

  16. Cities = important. Sustainable development will help to solve many problems.

    Reply

  17. MI: cities = important for innovative policies

    Reply

  18. MI: Cities best to tackle climate Δ, Emphasis on Econ + SDG, Ways to tackle climate Δ

    Reply

  19. With cities growing rapidly, sustainable development is crucial. Focus should be set on economic prosperity, social inclusion, and environmental sustainability.
    Governors and the lowest levels of goverment can help promote change in sustainable development, and are primarily responsible.
    With cities bringing in the majority of income, sustainability of these economies is critical for countries and the world in general.

    Reply

Leave a Reply